Shopping for A Wiki Tool?
Posted by Lucie deLaBruere
When educators ask me what tool I would recommend as an entry point to using Web 2.0 in education, I usually suggest “wikis” as a quick way to get started. WikiWiki is the Hawaiian term for “quick” and you can’t get much quicker than a wiki when trying to publish content to the world wide web.
For the web publishing consumer who desires “flexible design elements” with the ability to create a stunning and unique “look and feel” for their web content, a wiki is NOT the right tool. But if you are looking for easy and quick when publishing content to the web, you can’t get much more “wikiwiki” or “quick” than a wiki.
(Photo Credit)
In his book, Raw Materials for the Mind: A Teacher's Guide to Digital Literacy, David Warlick, suggest that we "Avoid training teachers to use sophisticated web editing software. Teachers are not web masters... they are communicators. Help them to communicate" (p. 280). Wikis not only help teachers and students to communicate, but to collaborate.
ITM blogger, Mark Wagner’s post about wikis and CUE article, "Why Wiki?" provide a great introduction to the world of wikis, as does his K-12 online conference session “Wiki While You Work”. Commoncraft’s reputation for short-easy to understand videos, offers another ‘quick’ introduction to help beginners understand wiki’s.
But even within the “quick and easy” world of wikis, more and more new features are being offered to cater to the needs of various type of consumers – including the educator. The features are so many that sites such as
http://www.wikimatrix.org/ have emerged to help you compare the features of over 100 wiki tools. Although such a matrix, can certainly help you understand the scope of features available with different tools, I believe that James Suroweiki and Malcolm Gladwell would agree that the best way to find out the ‘best wiki tool” for educators, is to ask other educators. I invite Infinite Thinking Readers to share their wiki experience in two areas. (1) What wiki features best meet the needs of educators and which wiki tools contain those features and (2) What are some examples of “wikis” used in exemplary ways in education.
I’ll start the conversation by highlighting two features that I feel are key to helping teachers get started with using wikis in their classrooms: 1) the cost of ‘free’ 2) simplicity.
If advertisements in exchange for “free” are keeping you away, check out sites like Wikispaces PBwiki, and WetPaint which offer educators “ad-free” wikis. Since 2006, the folks at wikispaces have been offering their Plus Plan (which usually sells for $50 a year) free to K-12 educators. This plan removes usage limits and advertisements for your educational wikis. It even allows you to set the wiki to private mode (where only “space members” can view and edit pages). To enroll in this program you must certify that your wiki space will be used for k12 education by signing up at http://www.wikispaces.com/site/for/teachers
I usually recommend Wikispaces for teachers just starting out using wiki’s because it is one of the simplest sites to manage. It may have less ‘features’ than other wiki tools, but sometimes LESS is MORE, when you are looking for a simple easy way to get started. Beginning teachers don’t miss “extra” seldom used features and welcome the simplicity. The one feature that I did miss is the ability to change font color – until last week. Thank you, to Adam Frey, and the folks at Wikispaces for adding this feature.
http://blog.wikispaces.com/2008/03/bringing-color-to-your-wiki.html.
Despite its simple, easy to use, interface, Wikispaces has included extra features that many educators will might find very useful as their use of wikis increases. Check out the “discussion” , “history”, and the “notify” me tab. The discussion tab allows users to communicate about a page without having to actually edit the page For example, a student can post new poetry on their page, and others can offer “comments” in the discussion area. The history tab allows you to ‘revert’ back to previous version of your wiki page, which is comforting in case of “accidentally” or “intentional” undesired changes. It also has a “compare” feature which makes for a great formative assessment tool for teachers looking to measure change over time in a student product. Finally the “notify me” tab is a great way for an educator to keep track of when someone makes changes to your wiki. This can be done with email notification or through an RSS feed. This will save an educator time, by giving him/her updates when their students or colleagues update their pages.
Even though the simplicity of wiki’s make them a very accessible tool to use in the classroom, the real key to using this collaboration tool lies in how these tools are used. Check out collections such as http://educationalwikis.wikispaces.com/ or educators.pbwiki.com/Best%20practices%20and%20examples to learn more ways to use wikis in education and to see hundreds of examples of education related wikis.
Other wiki tools I plan to cover in upcoming post because of their responsiveness to the needs of education are PBwiki, WetPaint and SeedWiki. Won't you help me, by sharing your favorite features of these wiki tools: What features you look for in a wiki tool and how has thus feature increases your effectiveness as a educator?
Labels: LuciedeLaBruere, Web 2.0, wikis










10 Comments:
Lucie:
I have actually used all of these tools. I tend to use Wetpaint more than the other two now for a variety of reasons, but all will definitely do the job. Biggest reason I use Wetpaint is the ability to bring in other types of media easier than I can in the other two tools. I'm a sucker for having a video embedded into one of my wiki pages, it makes me look cool...
Kyle
For personal productivity, I use MediaWiki, which Wikipedia runs on. However, I'm hesitant to use this with students because it lacks a true wysiwyg visual editor, which would require me to teach 6th graders how to use wikitext. The three hosted wikis you list do have visual editors and are much easier to use. However, it seems like setting up 150 student accounts would be awfully time consuming, and the process requires submitting student email addresses, and many of my students don't have those. How do other teachers get around this problem?
I have found pbwiki to meet my needs nicely! tmurdach.pbwiki.com
I like the point and click mode of editing as well as easiy being able to switch to the html code, too. The sidebar is a nice option to highlight information. Videos and images are easily inserted. I have a free pbwiki and have only found that I have run out of image space. I would recommend this wiki for anyone getting started and investigating how a wiki would meet their needs.
One of the best benefits of using a wiki is the ability to timeshift meetings and continue working with others after face-to-face time is over.
For teachers - Our tech committee has used a wiki to collaborate on staff development sessions.
My students use a wiki as an online workspace for publishing projects.
We have been using Wikispaces for over a year. For a good example of what college students can do with Wikispaces see nie.wikispaces.com
I'm a fan of PB Wiki. The advantage of PB Wiki over Wikispaces was an ability (which may have since been addressed) for students to make their way to public discussion forums in Wikispaces.
There was always inappropriate content on those boards that I couldn't control. PB Wiki provides spaces for closed community conversations, but not access to public boards.
I've really dived into wikis---both in the classroom and for professional development. Here's a post I wrote recently about addressing the risks of inappropriate content being posted by students:
http://tinyurl.com/38hyx2
And here's a PD wiki I put together recently for a session on Web 2.0 tools in the classroom:
http://digitallyspeaking.pbwiki.com
My favorite student wiki of all time is the NYC High School Writing Collaborative wiki:
http://schools.wikia.com/wiki/High_School_Online_Collaborative_Writing
Rock on,
Bill
Dear Bill:
(or Bam Bam Bigelow)
I just followd your links and looked over your materials. WOW... I certainly understand how you became Teacher of the Year and why your blog has won recent awards. This is exactly the type of sharing I was hoping from.
I loved the wiki page of your digital speaking wiki, especially the sructure and scoring you have come up with to guide your middle school students contributions to the wiki (Significant contribution or Constructive Modification).
http://digitallyspeaking.pbwiki.com/Wikis
I also appreciate the detail and thought you put into your reply to the question of "the risk of inappropriate content being posted by students" on your blog.
http://tinyurl.com/38hyx2
I bet a lot of readers would be interested in seeing what your "communication home" looks like as a model.
And thanks for the tips about pbwiki.com I will use your comments in my next post.
Thanks,
Lucie
Lucie,
Thanks for your post about wikis! As a former teacher that still works in the education space, I am excited by the potential of wikis in K12 education. I am working with a team of teachers, curricula writers and educators to create an early literacy wiki called www.FreeReading.net. Check it out! We are developing quite a large community of early literacy stakeholders!
Cheers,
Anna
www.FreeReading.net
www.LiteracyisPriceless.com
Hey Lucie,
Thanks a ton for your kind words on my work....but remember that three quarters of my thoughts are mashups of ideas shared freely in the edublog-o-sphere!
That's the beauty of the people who are writing publically and making their work transparent for all to use. We're making one another better teachers and the scale of our shared contributions is far greater than the difference we make alone.
Anyway,
Bill
PS...The Significant Contributions/Constructive Modifications wiki idea is a Darren Kuropatwa bit----you can find the link to his work in my wiki.
It's brilliant times ten. He does amazing things to "practical-ize" digital work for classroom teachers.
Just a clarification... some of the wikis you mentioned provide ad-free wikis for K12 teachers, but if their students are under 13 years of age, expect problems. One of our teachers had his students' parents help them create wetpaint accounts so they could be part of the class wiki. When he applied to have his wiki made ad-free, Wetpaint noticed the age of his students and shut him down rather than risk even appearing to be not complying with COPA. Our principal and tech director all wrote to Wetpaint, even quoting from the relevant parts of COPA to show we were not in violation, but they shut the wiki down anyhow.
Because of that, I've been directing my elementary teachers to wikispaces. They will set up individual accounts for students and age isn't an issue because the teacher creates the user name and password for the student and no other information is needed.
Post a Comment
<< Home